Welcome, sunuser7575 | Log out
Search: 
HOME | MARYLAND | NATION/WORLD | BUSINESS | SPORTS | ARTS/LIFE | OPINION | MARKETPLACE
Class action suit filed for Isabel flood victims
Attorneys claim insurers cheated policyholders
 
Photos

Photo galleries
Including photos submitted by readers

Graphics
Rebuilding after Tropical Storm Isabel

Rebuilding after Tropical Storm Isabel
Mar 21, 2004

Talk about it
Share your Hurricane Isabel experiences here.
Yup. Someone commented the other day that we hadn't torn the house down yet - well D'uh it sure is hard to get going when the contractors are too busy and you are still rounding up money.
Submitted by: WONDERING
Sep 8, 2004, 10:40 AM EDT
It works, but it tells me that most people in the state of Maryland, through the media, have forgotten there was a flood and the fact that many Isabel people are still homeless! I first noticed that about three weeks after the flood. We have all been “archived!”
Submitted by: GH
Sep 7, 2004, 1:18 PM EDT
Total Comments: 595
On The Web

Maryland Insurance Administration

Government's official storm tracking site

U.S. Hurricane Awareness Center

Most recent photo from space

Unisys Hurricane Data Center

Terrapin Hurricane Center

Sophisticated tracking and mapping

Also see
In Depth
Hurricane Isabel archived coverage

Hurricane Isabel archived coverage

Sun Staff
Originally published May 12, 2004
A Washington law firm filed suit yesterday in federal court on behalf of thousands of Tropical Storm Isabel victims, alleging that seven insurance companies systematically sought to shortchange flood policyholders.

The class action suit, apparently the first ever to target private insurance companies for their handling of policies from the federal government's flood insurance program, claims that victims were coerced to sign "proof of loss" forms that understated their damages. The suit also alleges that the insurance companies employed price guidelines that significantly underestimated the cost of labor and materials.

"After everything I've read and all the people I've talked to, I'm sickened, but I'm also sort of amazed by the consistency of how they've been treated," said Andrew Friedman, an attorney for Cohen, Millstein, Hausfeld and Toll, which filed the suit in U.S. District Court in Baltimore. "It's nothing short of amazing."

The plaintiffs are not requesting a specific amount of money, but they are asking:

  • That the insurance companies recalculate Isabel claims using appropriate price estimates for materials and labor.

  • That the companies refund flood insurance premiums that victims paid for policies in effect during the month when the storm hit.

  • That the companies be stripped of all profits and compensation they received for selling and servicing the policies.

    The complaint names seven plaintiffs from Anne Arundel, Baltimore and Talbot counties, but the suit could possibly affect 24,000 people from six states and the District of Columbia who filed claims after the storm.

    They, like many others, were told that if they did not sign a "proof of loss" form prepared by an adjuster before a deadline, they would receive nothing, Friedman said. And in many cases, the policyholders weren't told that the deadline had been extended, he said.

    The suit also claims that because adjusters are only paid after a claim is settled, they have an incentive to push flood victims into quick settlements and to err on the side of caution in deciding how much to offer, for fear that their work would be overruled by the third-party administrators who review claims.

    Charlene Kotrla, whose husband, Frederick, is one of the named plaintiffs, said the attorneys who filed the suit asked them not to discuss it.

    But Bernice Myer, a flood victim from Millers Island who has been a leader in the effort to have settlements re-evaluated, said a class action lawsuit is crucial because individual suits aren't feasible.

    "By the time you pay attorneys fees and court costs, you could end up in the hole financially," Myer said. "As an individual, you're standing in front of a double-barreled shotgun and hoping for the best."

    The defendants are: State Farm Insurance Companies, Omaha Property and Casualty, Travelers Property and Casualty, USAA General Indemnity Company, Selective Insurance Company of the Southeast, Indemnity Insurance Company of North America, and Harleysville Mutual Insurance Company.

    All seven companies either did not return phone messages yesterday or declined to comment because they had not had a chance to review the suit.

    Flood insurance is a federal government program, but in the 1980s, in an effort to encourage more people to buy coverage, the National Flood Insurance Program created a system in which private insurance companies sell and service policies.

    The suit comes amid the largest re-evaluation of claims in the history of the NFIP. Recognizing the widespread complaints from flood victims in the wake of Isabel, NFIP Director Anthony S. Lowe said in March that the agency would re-evaluate any Isabel claim in which the policyholder was dissatisfied.

    Steven B. Larsen, the former Maryland insurance commissioner who wrote a report on Isabel claims, said the filing of the suit was only a matter of time. "I think it was inevitable that a class action lawsuit would be filed based on the initial disclosures that have been made about the handling of claims," he said.

    Loretta Worters, a spokeswoman for the New York-based Insurance Information Institute, said this is the only instance she knows of in which private companies have been sued over federal flood claims. She questioned whether the lawsuit was appropriate since flood insurance is a federal program.

    Friedman said the private insurance companies are the proper target because the policies are a contract between the policyholders and the companies, not the government.

  • Copyright © 2004, The Baltimore Sun | Get home delivery

     





    Enter to win tickets to movies, concerts, festivals, sporting events and more. This month's featured contest: Phantom of the Opera tickets. Learn more about events sponsored by The Baltimore Sun and baltimoresun.com, including Baltimore's Best Darn Yard Sale.
    This month's featured section: Maryland Wedding. Purchase press plates of Sun front pages and logo merchandise.
    Welcome, sunuser7575 | Log out
    Search: